Sunday, March 29, 2026

Eagles Mere, Sullivan County Pa

 

Eagles Mere, Shrewsbury Twp, Sullivan County PA
An Index of Assorted History, Photos, Stories & Resources



==============
THE RESORTS
[INNS]
==============

 
Crestmont
1900-
 In 1892, a cyclone completely cleared a dense stand of Hemlock from a hill, at Eagles Mere.  In 1899  William Y. Warner of Philadelphia went to Eagles mere for a few weeks.  He had no intention of becoming a hotel proprietor.  ".. but when he observed the dominating position of 'cyclone hill'... he saw there an extraordinary site for a summer hotel."  Within a few weeks time Warner had purchased the site and arranged for an Inn to be constructed there.  The Crestmont Inn was ready for guests in June of 1900.

In 1911 when Mr. Warner died suddenly, his son in law William Woods took over the management.  In 1933, W. Tingle Dickerson, son in law of Mr. Woods, took over.
 
Edgemere
 Owned and Operated by the Eagles Mere Hotel company.
Located on Pennsylvania Avenue "At the turn of the road" just beyond the Presbyterian Chapel.

The Edgemere began as the Eagles Mere (Point Breeze) Hotel.  This structure suffered a minor fire, and was moved into "this new position", where it was rebuilt, refurnished, and renamed.
 
Forest
 
 
Lakeside
1880-1962  - Demolished in 1962
 
 
Raymond
-1942 Destroyed By Fire

 "which was for a long time a landmark on the west shore of the lake, where it occupied an admirable situation overlooking the lake and within easy walking distance of Eagles Mere Village and Bathing Beach.  for many years it was operated by William L. Laird.  Following his death it  managed by the Eagles Mere Company until it was completely destroyed by fire late in 1942.  The site was sold to a contiguous cottage owner and has since been turned into a lawn." - 



From 1945-1965 The Eagles Mere Playhouse, owned by the Forest Inn, was rented by Lucy McCammon and Miss Krause.  it featured performers such as Patricia Neal, Jimmy Gheen, Charlton Heston, Jennifer Jones, Paula Prentiss, and Richard Benjamin.

===========
Smaller Hotels
As listed in Eagles Mere and the Sullivan Highlands 
by McFarland, 1944
============
The Eagles Mere Inn
Formerly the Hotel Lewis
Located on Mary Avenue

The Allegheny Hotel
1885-
Corner of Laporte and Allegheny Avenues across from the Methodist Church
Four Stories Tall, 44 rooms, open year round, could accommodate 125 guests.  Closed as a hotel in 1960, used by Eagles Mere Athletic Assoc as a youth Center and employee dormitory.  Torn down in 1979.  

The Flora Villa
 Just west of the Eagles Mere Post Office

The Lake Shore Inn
Facing the Lake outlet

The Eagle Inn
On Eagles Mere Avenue

Eagles Mere Cottages
"In addition to the hotels and cottages previously mentioned in this book, there are, in Eagles Mere borough, south and west of the lake, some 85 cottages, large and small, which are used for summer residence only" - McFarland


=============
EVENTS
=============

The Eagles Mere Toboggan Slide
First built in 1903, it continues to be built when the winter weather cooperates.
Read more about it's history here:

The Eagles Mere Water Carnival
See More Here

=============
THE LAKE
=============


============
THE RAILROAD
==============
See more photos of trains in and around Eagles Mere, including the Williamsport and North Branch line, here:
https://www.facebook.com/share/p/18KccHvi3R/

Read more about the Eagles Mere Railroad here:


Read more about Castle Rock here:


There's a fantastic model train display in the Eagles Mere Museum


=============
BOOKS  & BOOKLETS
==============

 

Historical Fiction 


 READ ONLINE FREE HERE

 

 

Eagles Mere
Reverie

 

Includes List of Cottages

 


============
MAPS
============
Sullivan County 1895





Sullivan County was established on March 15, 1847 from Lycoming County.

============
VISITING TODAY
Things To See
============


===============
READ MORE
===============


Embley S. Chase came to Eagles Mere in 1886 and helped to turn the area into a popular resort town.

Assorted Notes:
   Mrs. Harry G. Clay, of this city, is collecting funds
to erect a chapel at Eagles Mere. (year unknown, included in the newspaper clippings of Walt Whitman) 

Displayed at the 1895 Lycoming County Centennial: " Judge  C.  D.  Eldred,  pane  of  bull's-eye  glass,  made  at  Eagles  Mere at  the  beginning  of  the  century,  by  the  Englishman  Lewis." 

--------------------

The land around what is now known as Eagles Mere Lake was first purchased by Charles Walstoncraft, a prominent Philadelphian.  He then sold the lake, along with over 10,000 acres, to George Lewis in 1794.  Lewis then surveyed the land, planned a community, and took advantage of the lake’s sandy beach to begin a glassworks in 1803.  However, his endeavor floundered with the onset of the trade restrictions brought on by the War of 1812 and it was defunct by 1829.  The lake and surrounding land went through various owners until a group of four businessmen created what came to be known as the Syndicate and began what would become a resort community in 1877.  This Syndicate, the forerunner of the present-day Eagles Mere Association, promoted their resort, built its infrastructure, groomed its beach and laid out its famous hiking trails.

As the resort became more popular, more vacation and summer homes were constructed in the form of cottages.  Built in the Queen Anne, American Craftsman, Prairie School and Shingle architectural styles, these cottages comprise the largest number of contributing buildings.  However, due to a restrictive covenant that prohibited building and clear-cutting along the lakeshore, these cottages are located primarily along Eagles Mere, Pennsylvania and Lakewood Avenues, which encircle the lake.  Today, the district is divided into five sections: the original village, Pennsylvania Avenue, Crestmont and Lakewood Avenues, the park/beach section, and Lake and Shoreline Avenues.

The district’s commercial structures are primarily centered within the town of Eagles Mere and include Miller’s Drug Store (1903), the Sweet Shop (1885), the Eagles Mere Fire Company and Community Hall (1942) and the former Post Office (1902).  Also located within the town is the museum which is devoted to the 200+ year history of the area.  Its exhibits include The George Lewis Glassworks Era, 1804-1830; The Farming Era, 1830-1880; and The Big Hotels’ Era, 1880-1960s.  Also located at the museum is the Visitor Information Center.

Other prominent contributors to the district are its boathouses and beach area located at the lake’s northern end as well as its four churches.  St. John’s-in-the-Wilderness Episcopal Church was built in 1894 and is one of the few all stone buildings in the district and the original section of the St. Francis of Assisi Catholic Church was built in 1905. 





Tuesday, March 24, 2026

4th Street Williamsport - Block By Block Through the Decades


[A Rough Draft Of]
A Postcard Tour of 4th Street In Williamsport
Block By Block Through The Decades

If you are viewing this page, please know that at this point, you are viewing my research process - not a finished project.   Eventually I will add the images from Sanborn maps, information from directories, and a LOT more photos.   This is just a very rough start, primarily for perspective on the 1936 flood photos, at the moment.  [If I put the flood photos in order by location, I can spot which ones are not from the 1936 flood.  Quite a few 1940s photos are mislabeled 1936]  These postcard tours are one of the most time consuming projects I tackle.

===================
East 4th - Basin to Academy
===================
===================
East 4th - Academy to East
===================
===================
East 4th - East to Mulberry
===================
Judge Gamble's Home, 4th & Mulberry


===================
East 4th - Mulberry to State
====================

On the right, the Elks Building [City Church
across the intersection, on the left, Christ Episcopal Church
Mulberry is the street that runs alongside the Christ Episcopal Church

==================
East 4th - State To Market
===================

Looking down on the library, on the left
Parsons House to the left of the library

Masonic Temple on the right

The James V. Brown Library on the left

James V. Brown Library

James V. Brown Library On Right
Masonic building on left


Northeast Corner of 4th and Market
East Fourth and Market Streets. On reverse of photo: "Built by Anson V. Parson, approximately 1839, shortly bought by Hezekiah Packer (brother of William), then Fischer family (relatives of Jonas), then Weizel. Twin of J V Brown house"


400 is Firestone Building
(North West Corner of Market and 4th)

South west corner of Market & 4th - Masonic Temple Building

===================
West 4th - Market to Court
====================

Corner of 4th and Market - Cillos today


4th & Market after the 36 Flood - Nardis

=================
West 4th - Court to Pine
==================

1903

Updegraff Hotel (1892)
Southwest Corner of Pine and 4th
The Updegraff Hotel was at the corner of 4th & Pine
The address today would be 47 West Fourth Street.

Daniel Updegraff (brother of abolitionist Abraham) built this hotel, the largest of its day in the city, on the site of the old Hepburn Inn, where abolitionist Fredrick Douglass spoke when he came to Williamsport in the 1870’s.

The building still stands today, as the City Center Building. 

Hess Building
corner of Pine & 4th
Mercantile Agency
( I can't quite place this - the Sanborn Map may help. )


==================
West 4th - Pine to Laurel
========================

1903 " Above Laurel"

Looking East On West Fourth from Pine St
On the left - Waltons
On the Right - Philadelphia & Reading Railway, Hanks


Looking through the intersection of 4th and pine, 1936 flood

Grant
Bank (Visitors center today)

Breon Drugs
United Cigars
 Hotel
Ligetts Drugs
Western Union

Hotel on the right, on the other side of the intersection, would later be the Hotel Updegraff, and today, Center City Apartments at 47 West Fourth.

Southeast Corner of 4th and Pine
Hotel
United Cigars


1936 flood

Looking south on Pine, through the 4th St intersection
Unites Cigars & Hotel on left [Hotel Updegraff/Center City Apartments]

North side of the street
Bank (Visitors center today)
Grant (Parking Lot today)
Jc Penny (Parking Lot today)
Sears
Wahlbraun

See a LOT more about Krims here: 

Thrift drugs on left (today Gustonian)

Thrift Drugs  (Today Gustonian Gifts)


================
West 4th - Laurel to William
==================
In 1902, Gorman's Floral was in 137 West Fourth  - that would be to the right of the 

Keeney's Grand Theater  138 West Fourth
Early 1920s.  Renamed Roxy in the 30s.
[Clothier Today]


Atlantic & Pacific
141 Housel & Co

On Google Maps, 2026

West 4th street, Williamsport Pa. Looking east from Williams Street. Year ?? Great view of the trolley and trolley tracks. Lots of wallpaper stores!

On the right, above the horse, look for the double window with the rounded top - today that is Miles Welby A Candle Co. M 151 W. 4th Street (beside the The Crooked Goose )

Looking on down the street (the photo is looking east) the tall building would have been the Hotel Updegraff - today Center City Apartments, 47 West Fourth Street.

On the Southeast Corner of  4th & William
Today, Crooked Goose & Miles Welby 
1930s cars?

On the Southeast Corner of  4th & William
Hazelets  (Today, Crooked Goose & Miles Welby )

==================
West 4th - William to Government
=====================
 Southwest Corner of William & 4th
Home of John A. Otto, West Fourth Street and William Street. Became the Ross Club and then headquarters for the First Community Foundation Partnership of Pennsylvania.

Photo from c. 1900
Ross Club is on the Southwest Corner of William & 4th

Ross Club on the right
Lycoming Cycle Co
Tailor

Western Union Telegraph
""This picture was taken in front of the Western Union Telegraph Co when it was located in the YMCA bldg on the south side of 4th street between Government Place and William Street in 1900. "
READ MORE ABOUT THIS PHOTO HERE

On the right is the Lycoming [Genetti] Hotel
& The Capitol Movie Theater [Community Arts Center Building]


Kelchners Lunch
Corabrese
Dine-Ett
Capitol Theater

Lyoming Hotel [200 W. 4th Genetti today]

North Side of the Street - 
Dairy Store
Capitol Theater
[Community Arts Center Today]

Inspiration Lycoming Mural & Bullfrog Across the street


=====================
West 4th - Government to Hepburn
====================



Looking East from Government Place
Post office on right
on left is a sign for Williamsport Commercial college and school of shorthand
and Vandersloot Music Co

=================
West 4th -"Above Hepburn"
=================

1903, "Above Hepburn"
Today this area is a parking lot/town clock/mini park - across from the AMC theater

Porters Central Hotel
? Winner?
313 The Evening News



On the very edge of the right you can make out the Evening News Building beside the Post Office.


Dunlop Tires
Wolf Furniture

Post office to the right.  The photo above would the building on the other side of the cars (if it still stood in the 1940s)


===================================
Millionaires Row & On Out 4th

West 4th and Elmira in the 1936 Flood
Today this is the City Alliance Church


Herdic House/Park Hotel 1936 Flood

Weightman building on left



==================
TO SORT 
=================

Looking East on Fourth Street 
Lycoming Cycle

Bernard Steuben Merchant Tailor
Keywest Cigars
Hardware Stoves and Tinware
Central Music ? Pianos & Organs
Stone??? Grocer

And the trolley on the tracks


===============


SAVE FOR WHEN I START 3rd ST:

East 4th - Basin to Academy

East 4th - Academy to East

East 4th - East to Mulberry

East 4th - Mulberry to State

East 4th - State To Market

West 4th - Market to Court

West 4th - Court to Pine

West 4th - Pine to Laurel

West 4th - Laurel to William

West 4th - William to Goverment

West 4th - Government to Hepburn